What proof is there that Jesus came to Earth?

27-Jun-2025
Peter W. Guess

jesus, jesus people movement

1. What Proof is There That Jesus Came to Earth?

Historical and Scholarly Evidence:

📜 1. Non-Christian Sources

  • Tacitus (c. 55–120 AD): Roman historian who mentions Jesus’ execution by Pontius Pilate.
  • Josephus (c. 37–100 AD): Jewish historian who wrote about Jesus, calling Him a “wise man” and referencing His crucifixion.
  • Pliny the Younger (c. 61–113 AD): Roman governor who wrote to Emperor Trajan about early Christians worshiping “Christ as a god.”

🪨 Archaeological Evidence

  • Ancient inscriptions and places (like Pilate’s name on a stone in Caesarea) confirm people and events described in the Gospels.

📖 New Testament Documents

  • Multiple independent sources (the four Gospels, Paul’s letters) attest to Jesus’ life and ministry.
  • Most scholars agree these texts were written within 30–60 years of Jesus’ death, close enough to be tested by eyewitnesses.

🔎 Eyewitness Testimony

  • The apostles claimed firsthand experience of Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection—and many died for this claim.

🧠 Scholarly Consensus

  • Even secular historians accept that Jesus of Nazareth was a real person who lived in the 1st century.

📚 2. Josh McDowell in "Evidence That Demands a Verdict"

Josh McDowell’s book is a classic in Christian apologetics, first published in 1972 and updated since. His basic approach is to marshal historical and textual evidence to show that:

🌟 2a. Jesus Existed and Was Crucified

  • McDowell gathers ancient texts and archaeological data to demonstrate that Jesus was a historical figure who was crucified.

📜 2b. Reliability of the New Testament

  • He argues that the NT documents are trustworthy historical sources—well-attested by thousands of manuscripts and early dating.
  • Compares them to other ancient texts (like Homer or Caesar) to show their superior historical basis.

💥 2c. Resurrection as Historical Fact

  • McDowell says the resurrection is the best explanation for the empty tomb, the changed lives of the disciples, and the birth of the early church.
  • He lays out what he calls a “minimal facts” approach:
    • Jesus died by crucifixion
    • He was buried
    • His tomb was empty
    • Disciples had experiences they believed were appearances of the risen Jesus
    • The early church rapidly grew, despite persecution

🏛️ 3. Conclusion

  • If the NT is historically reliable, and Jesus rose from the dead, then Jesus’ claims about Himself are true.
  • Therefore, Jesus truly is the Son of God, and His message demands a verdict—a response from each of us.

📝 In Short:

Jesus’ historical existence is supported by secular sources, archaeology, and early Christian writings.
Josh McDowell’s book argues that the historical data—especially the resurrection—compels a decision about Jesus’ identity.
For skeptics, McDowell’s approach is to start with historical facts and show that they lead to a supernatural conclusion.

Josh McDowell’s key arguments from Evidence That Demands a Verdict, covering how he builds his case step by step. I’ll add context and examples so it’s easy to understand and share.

🔍 1. Historical Reliability of the New Testament

McDowell devotes a large part of his book to showing that the New Testament (NT) documents are historically reliable:

📜 Manuscript Evidence

  • Thousands of Greek NT manuscripts (over 5,800 partial or complete copies).
  • Compared to other ancient works (like Homer’s Iliad or Caesar’s Gallic Wars), the NT is unparalleled in manuscript support.

Ancient Work

Earliest Copy

Time Gap

Copies

Homer’s Iliad

400 BC

500 years

1,757

Caesar’s Gallic Wars

900 AD

1,000 years

10

New Testament

130 AD

30–60 years

5,800+

 

1. What Proof is There That Jesus Came to Earth?

Historical and Scholarly Evidence:

📜 Non-Christian Sources

·         Tacitus (c. 55–120 AD): Roman historian who mentions Jesus’ execution by Pontius Pilate.

·         Josephus (c. 37–100 AD): Jewish historian who wrote about Jesus, calling Him a “wise man” and referencing His crucifixion.

·         Pliny the Younger (c. 61–113 AD): Roman governor who wrote to Emperor Trajan about early Christians worshiping “Christ as a god.”

🪨 Archaeological Evidence

·         Ancient inscriptions and places (like Pilate’s name on a stone in Caesarea) confirm people and events described in the Gospels.

📖 New Testament Documents

·         Multiple independent sources (the four Gospels, Paul’s letters) attest to Jesus’ life and ministry.

·         Most scholars agree these texts were written within 30–60 years of Jesus’ death, close enough to be tested by eyewitnesses.

🔎 Eyewitness Testimony

·         The apostles claimed firsthand experience of Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection—and many died for this claim.

🧠 Scholarly Consensus

·         Even secular historians accept that Jesus of Nazareth was a real person who lived in the 1st century.


📚 2. Josh McDowell in "Evidence That Demands a Verdict"

Josh McDowell’s book is a classic in Christian apologetics, first published in 1972 and updated since. His basic approach is to marshal historical and textual evidence to show that:

🌟 a. Jesus Existed and Was Crucified

·         McDowell gathers ancient texts and archaeological data to demonstrate that Jesus was a historical figure who was crucified.

📜 b. Reliability of the New Testament

·         He argues that the NT documents are trustworthy historical sources—well-attested by thousands of manuscripts and early dating.

·         Compares them to other ancient texts (like Homer or Caesar) to show their superior historical basis.

💥 c. Resurrection as Historical Fact

·         McDowell says the resurrection is the best explanation for the empty tomb, the changed lives of the disciples, and the birth of the early church.

·         He lays out what he calls a “minimal facts” approach:

o    Jesus died by crucifixion

o    He was buried

o    His tomb was empty

o    Disciples had experiences they believed were appearances of the risen Jesus

o    The early church rapidly grew, despite persecution

🏛️ d. Conclusion

·         If the NT is historically reliable, and Jesus rose from the dead, then Jesus’ claims about Himself are true.

·         Therefore, Jesus truly is the Son of God, and His message demands a verdict—a response from each of us.


📝 In Short:

✅ Jesus’ historical existence is supported by secular sources, archaeology, and early Christian writings.
✅ Josh McDowell’s book argues that the historical data—especially the resurrection—compels a decision about Jesus’ identity.
✅ For skeptics, McDowell’s approach is to start with historical facts and show that they lead to a supernatural conclusion.

 

Absolutely! Let’s break down Josh McDowell’s key arguments from Evidence That Demands a Verdict, covering how he builds his case step by step. I’ll add context and examples so it’s easy to understand and share.


🔍 1. Historical Reliability of the New Testament

McDowell devotes a large part of his book to showing that the New Testament (NT) documents are historically reliable:

📜 Manuscript Evidence

·         Thousands of Greek NT manuscripts (over 5,800 partial or complete copies).

·         Compared to other ancient works (like Homer’s Iliad or Caesar’s Gallic Wars), the NT is unparalleled in manuscript support.

Ancient Work

Earliest Copy

Time Gap

Copies

Homer’s Iliad

400 BC

500 years

1,757

Caesar’s Gallic Wars

900 AD

1,000 years

10

New Testament

130 AD

30–60 years

5,800+

🧪 Early Dating and Eyewitness Testimony

·         Many letters (like Paul’s) are dated within 20–30 years of Jesus’ death.

·         Eyewitnesses were still alive to challenge any false claims.

🏛️ External Corroboration

·         Non-Christian sources (Tacitus, Josephus, Pliny, Suetonius) confirm key facts about Jesus and the early Christians.

·         Archaeology (like the Pilate Stone, pool of Bethesda) supports the Gospel’s cultural and geographical accuracy.


🌟 2. Jesus’ Claims and Identity

McDowell argues that Jesus didn’t leave room for Him to be seen as just a “good teacher”:

🗣️ Direct Claims

·         Jesus said He was the Son of God (Mark 14:61–62).

·         Claimed to forgive sins (Mark 2:5–7).

·         Said He would judge the world (Matthew 25:31–32).

·         Equated Himself with God (John 10:30).

🪞 Indirect Claims

·         He accepted worship (Matthew 14:33).

·         Used divine titles like “I AM” (John 8:58, echoing God’s name in Exodus 3:14).


⚖️ 3. The Trilemma Argument (Liar, Lunatic, or Lord)

McDowell uses C.S. Lewis’ trilemma:

“If Jesus’ claims are true, He is Lord. If false, He either knew it (Liar) or didn’t (Lunatic).”

·         Liar: A deliberate fraud who was morally flawed.

·         Lunatic: A sincere but deluded man (like someone thinking they’re Napoleon).

·         Lord: His claims are true, and He is who He said He was.

McDowell says Jesus’ moral character and the impact of His teachings make “Liar” or “Lunatic” unlikely—leaving “Lord” as the best explanation.


💥 4. The Resurrection as the Central Proof

McDowell calls the resurrection the lynchpin—if true, it validates Jesus’ claims:

🪦 Key Points of Evidence

·         Empty Tomb:

o    Women found it first (in that culture, women’s testimony wasn’t valued—an unlikely made-up detail).

o    Roman/Jewish leaders never produced a body.

·         Post-Resurrection Appearances:

o    Multiple independent appearances to individuals and groups.

o    Paul’s letters mention 500 witnesses (1 Corinthians 15:6).

·         Transformed Disciples:

o    From scared, defeated men to bold preachers, willing to die for their testimony.

💡 Alternate Theories Rebutted

McDowell systematically rebuts common theories:

Theory

Why it Fails

Swoon Theory

Roman execution expertise & burial practices would prevent survival.

Stolen Body

Disciples would not die for what they knew was a lie.

Hallucination Theory

Hallucinations don’t happen in groups or over time.

Wrong Tomb

Authorities could have corrected the error easily.


📚 5. The Impact of Jesus and Christianity

McDowell also points out:

✅ Christianity exploded despite intense persecution.
✅ Jesus’ teachings on love, forgiveness, and the dignity of all people revolutionized culture.


🔑 McDowell’s Conclusion: “The Evidence Demands a Verdict”

Because:

·         The NT is historically reliable

·         Jesus claimed to be God and lived out that claim

·         The resurrection is the best explanation for the empty tomb and changed disciples

👉 McDowell says each person must decide:
Who is Jesus to you?


🌟 Summary of Key Arguments

Key Argument

Summary Point

NT Reliability

Early, abundant manuscripts and external confirmations.

Jesus’ Claims

Direct and indirect claims to divinity—He didn’t claim to be just a teacher.

Liar, Lunatic, or Lord?

His moral life and teaching make Liar/Lunatic unlikely—so Lord.

Resurrection Evidence

Empty tomb, eyewitness testimony, changed lives.

Christianity’s Impact

The faith’s explosive growth and transformation of history.


Would you like a short version of this to use in a talk, or even a study outline for small groups? Let me know how you’d like to use this, and I can tailor it!

========================================

🎤 Evidence for Jesus: Key Points (Short Talk Outline)

1. Historical Reliability

  • The New Testament has thousands of early manuscripts, more than any other ancient text.
  • Non-Christian historians like Tacitus and Josephus confirm Jesus’ existence and crucifixion.

2. Jesus’ Claims

  • Jesus didn’t just teach love and forgiveness—He claimed to be the Son of God and accepted worship.
  • His words and actions show He believed He was more than just a prophet.

3. Liar, Lunatic, or Lord?

  • If His claims were false, He was either a liar or deluded.
  • But His moral teaching and life make those unlikely.
  • So, the best explanation is: He was telling the truth—He’s Lord.

4. The Resurrection

  • Empty tomb: No one could produce a body.
  • Eyewitnesses: Over 500 people saw Him alive again.
  • Changed lives: His disciples went from hiding to boldly proclaiming the resurrection—many died for it.

5. Impact of Christianity

  • Despite persecution, Christianity spread rapidly and transformed cultures with its message of hope and dignity.

🔑 Conclusion

  • Josh McDowell says: The evidence demands a verdict.
  • If Jesus really rose from the dead, He is who He claimed to be—the Son of God.
  • What will you do with this evidence?